Let’s get something straight.

You cannot stop recruiters from calling your best people.

And honestly… you shouldn’t want to.

What you can do is build a culture so strong, so aligned, and so human that when those calls come in, your people say:

“Thanks - but I’m good where I am.”

That’s a poach-proof culture.

Not locked in by fear.

Not held together by golden handcuffs.

But anchored by trust, meaning, and consistency.

First - what poaching really exposes

When a great employee leaves after one LinkedIn message, it’s rarely about the money.

Poaching works when:

• People already feel unseen
• Growth feels blocked
• Leadership feels inconsistent
• Values feel optional
• Trust has quietly eroded

The recruiter didn’t cause the exit.

They just opened the door that was already unlocked.

Poach-proof cultures don’t rely on loyalty speeches

Telling people to “be loyal” doesn’t work.

Neither do retention bonuses without substance.

Poach-proof cultures are built on experience, not expectation.

People stay when:

• They feel respected, not managed
• They trust leadership decisions, even when they don’t agree
• They understand how success is measured and rewarded
• They feel safe to speak up without career consequences
• Their growth is intentional, not accidental

If those things are missing, no counter-offer will save you.

The real foundations of a poach-proof culture

1. Consistent leadership behaviour

People don’t leave because leaders are imperfect.

They leave because leaders are unpredictable.

Mood-based leadership creates anxiety.

Clear, consistent standards create trust.

If your leaders behave one way under pressure and another when things are calm, your culture isn’t stable - it’s conditional.

2. Growth that isn’t vague or delayed

Top performers don’t want “someday.”

They want clarity.

If development conversations are always postponed…

If career paths are unclear…

If feedback only arrives during performance reviews…

Someone else will offer what you haven’t defined.

Growth doesn’t need to be vertical.

It needs to be visible.

3. Values that cost something

Values only matter when they’re inconvenient.

If results excuse poor behaviour, your values aren’t real.

If senior people aren’t held to the same standard, trust collapses fast.

Poach-proof cultures protect values even when it’s uncomfortable - because people notice who gets protected and who gets promoted.

4. Recognition that reinforces the right behaviour

What you reward teaches people how to behave.

If speed beats quality every time…

If loud voices beat thoughtful ones…

If output beats integrity…

That becomes the culture.

Recognition isn’t about praise.

It’s about clarity.

5. Psychological safety, not performative openness

If people have to rehearse what they say before meetings, your culture isn’t safe.

It’s political.

Poach-proof cultures allow disagreement without punishment.

They reward honesty, not harmony.

And they treat feedback as data, not disrespect.

The uncomfortable truth

If your best people are entertaining external conversations, they’re already halfway gone emotionally.

And the fix is rarely a pay rise.

It’s leadership behaviour.

It’s alignment.

It’s trust.

Poach-proof cultures aren’t built to trap people.

They’re built so people choose to stay.

Final thought

You’ll never outbid every competitor.

But you can out-care them.

Out-lead them.

Out-align them.

And when you do, recruiters stop being a threat

and start being a compliment.

That’s a poach-proof culture.

Want more FREE content around building culture and hiring?  👉 https://jmp.sh/Blgq4f8A